top of page

Find a match in < 3 minutes
Answer below to see who among our team might be best equipped for your therapy goals.
Step 1 of 5
Who is therapy for?
Common Questions
On Finding a Therapist

Everyone talks about finding the "right fit," but how am I supposed to know what that feels like when I’m already anxious about opening up to a stranger?It is completely normal to feel nervous at first, so instead of looking for instant comfort, pay attention to whether you feel heard, respected, and safe from judgment. Decades of research show that the bond you build with your therapist (feeling like they truly "get" you and are on your side) is the single biggest predictor of whether therapy will actually help. We call this "Goodness of Fit." If you leave your first couple of sessions feeling understood and hopeful that this person can help you reach your goals, you are likely in the right place.
I see so many acronyms online for different types of therapy, and I’m overwhelmed. How do I know which method will actually fix what I’m going through?Studies consistently show that who your therapist is matters much more than the specific techniques they use, so you don't need to have the methods all figured out before you start. What leads to the best results is when you and your therapist agree on what you are working toward and how you are going to get there together. During your intake, describe what you are struggling with and ask how they typically help people in your shoes. If their approach makes sense to you, that is what counts.
Is it wrong to want a therapist who shares my background or life experiences? I’m exhausted by the thought of having to explain my culture or identity before we even get to my actual problems.It is not wrong at all, and wanting to skip the exhausting work of educating your therapist is a very valid reason to look for someone who shares your identity. That said, data shows that the best outcomes don't necessarily require an exact background match, but rather a therapist who approaches your life with deep respect, cultural curiosity, and zero defensiveness. Whether your therapist shares your background or not, you deserve someone who makes room for your whole identity and never assumes they know your experience better than you do.
I don't want to give up too soon, but I also don't want to waste months of time and money if we aren't clicking. How long does it usually take to know if therapy is working?You usually don't need to wait months to tell if a match is working; research shows that people who experience strong results typically feel a solid connection within the first three to five sessions. While deep healing takes time, you should start to feel a sense of relief, clarity, or small shifts in your day-to-day life within the first month or two. If you are four sessions in and still feel misunderstood or disconnected, it is completely okay to bring that up or look for someone new.
What am I supposed to do if my therapist gives me advice that feels totally off, or says something that rubs me the wrong way? I hate confrontation and feel like I’d just shut down.It can feel scary to speak up, but telling your therapist when they have missed the mark is actually one of the most powerful things you can do for your progress. Research proves that the most effective therapists aren't the ones who never make mistakes, but the ones who welcome your honest feedback and adjust their approach without getting defensive. If you say, "That didn't really land for me," a great therapist will thank you for telling them and work with you to get back on the same page.
Should I only look for someone with a doctorate or twenty years of experience? I want to make sure I’m getting the best help possible, especially if I’m paying out of pocket.Surprisingly, studies show that a therapist's type of degree or years on the job have very little impact on how much their clients actually improve. Often, newer therapists or those with master's degrees are just as effective, and may be even more attentive and collaborative than some seasoned veterans. Instead of focusing on the letters after their name, focus on how present they are with you, how well they listen, and whether they regularly check in to see if therapy is helping you.
Part of me feels guilty even looking for a therapist because nothing tragic has happened to me. What if I get in there and they think I’m just complaining about normal life stuff?A therapist should never "grade your pain on a curve" or make you feel like you need to be in a crisis to deserve support. In fact, starting therapy when you are simply feeling stuck, overwhelmed, or disconnected often leads to faster, more meaningful breakthroughs because you have the energy to dig in. If something matters enough to weigh on your mind, it matters enough to bring to therapy.
I’m worried I’ll just end up rambling for an hour while someone nods and asks, "How does that make you feel?" Is it okay to ask for actual direction and feedback?Yes, and asking for what you need right from the start is one of the best ways to ensure therapy actually works for you. The most successful therapy happens when the style of the sessions matches your personal preferences, whether you want structured homework and practical tools, or a quiet space to untangle your thoughts. During your intake, tell your provider: "I do best with an active conversation and practical takeaways," and get their thoughts on how what you're looking for specifically can be incorporated into your care.
Between work and life, driving to an office every week feels almost impossible, but I’m worried video therapy will feel too distant. Will I get as much out of it if we aren't in the same room?Extensive research shows video therapy is just as effective as in-person therapy for the vast majority of challenges, including anxiety and depression. What makes therapy work is consistency and emotional honesty, so if logging in from your couch means you can actually show up every week without added stress, online therapy is the better choice. If you try video sessions and still crave the boundary of a physical room outside your home, you can always adjust down the road.
What if I try a few sessions with someone who is really nice, but I can tell they just aren't the right match for me? I feel terrible at the thought of "breaking up" with them and hurting their feelings, or it just being super awkward.You're in luck: Therapists are trained for this. Called "Termination" in the industry, good therapists always keep the wind-down process of a therapeutic relationship in mind, and they don't take it personally when clients decide that end may be needed because of a mismatch. In fact, good therapists use these experiences to deepen their skills even further. At Redfish, your therapist's top priority is that you get the care you need, even if it isn't with them (or us). You don't owe anyone a long explanation; a simple message letting your provider or our admin team know you don't feel like this is the right fit for what you need is completely sufficient. As licensed clinicians, each of our therapists will wish you well and will offer to send you referrals for other resources who might be a better match. *One thing to consider: we always encourage clients to let their therapist know if they feel a mismatch is happening. Sometimes a quick conversation about this can lead to dramatic improvements in the therapy experience and even greater alignment between what a client needs and what a therapist can provide!
bottom of page